TL;DR
More than 600 UC faculty members, led by UC Berkeley mathematicians, are urging the university system to reinstate standardized testing requirements for STEM admissions starting in fall 2027. They cite evidence of significant math deficiencies among incoming students, which hampers their success in college-level STEM courses.
More than 600 University of California faculty members, led by mathematicians at UC Berkeley, are demanding the reinstatement of standardized testing requirements for STEM applicants, citing ‘severe’ math deficits among incoming students.
The open letter, addressed to UC leaders, calls for SAT or ACT exams to be required for STEM admissions beginning in fall 2027. The faculty argue that six years without standardized testing has failed to reliably assess student readiness, with many students showing significant gaps in math skills upon entry.
According to the letter, at least 20% of first-semester calculus students at UC Berkeley showed math deficits on diagnostic exams between fall 2021 and fall 2023. The faculty warn that these gaps hinder students’ ability to succeed in college-level STEM courses, with some instructors having to reteach middle school math.
Why It Matters
This development is significant because it signals a potential shift in UC admissions policy amid concerns about student preparedness for rigorous STEM programs. Reinstating standardized testing could impact access and diversity, but proponents argue it is necessary to ensure students are academically ready for college-level work, which affects the quality of STEM education and the university’s reputation.
SAT Math Workbook: Up-to-Date Practice for the Digital Exam (Barron's SAT Prep)
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Background
The UC system suspended SAT and ACT requirements in 2020, citing concerns over bias and access disparities, with plans to eliminate them by 2025. However, legal challenges and pandemic-related disruptions led to the suspension being extended. Several peer institutions, including Harvard and Stanford, have reinstated standardized testing requirements for applicants in recent years. The UC Academic Senate previously expressed skepticism about the effectiveness of test-optional policies, citing research that suggests test scores are better predictors of college success than high school grades.
Recent reports, including a UC San Diego study, highlight increasing math deficiencies among incoming students, raising alarms about their preparedness for STEM fields.
“Our letter is going to be attacked from all sides. But I see the SAT as a tool to help disadvantaged students, not hurt them. Right now, lack of SATs is hurting underrepresented minorities because students who fail the test are admitted without the skills to succeed.”
— Zvezda Stankova, Berkeley mathematics professor
“We are aware of concerns about student preparedness and are working on a roadmap of policy work and collaboration with K-12 and higher education leaders to address these issues.”
— Ahmet Palazoglu, chair of UC Academic Senate
ACT Test Prep: The Complete and Fully Updated Prep Book to Ace the ACT Exam with Full-Length Practice Tests and Easy-to-Follow Explanations
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
What Remains Unclear
It remains unclear whether UC leadership will fully endorse reinstating standardized testing requirements or how they will balance concerns about access and equity with academic preparedness. The upcoming UC Academic Senate discussions will clarify potential policy shifts.
SAT Total Prep 2026: Includes 4 Full Length Practice Tests, 1,100+ Practice Questions + 1 Year Access to Online Quizzes and Video Lessons and Tutorials (Kaplan Test Prep)
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
What’s Next
The UC Academic Senate’s Board of Admissions and Relations with Schools is scheduled to review admissions policies soon, which may include proposals to reintroduce standardized testing for STEM applicants. Further decisions are expected in the coming months.
ACT Total Prep 2026: Includes 6 Full Length Tests, 2,000+ Practice Questions + Online Access to a 500+ Question Bank & Video Tutorials (Kaplan Test Prep)
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
Why are UC faculty calling for the return of standardized tests?
They argue that recent data shows significant math deficits among incoming students, which hinder their success in STEM fields. Faculty believe standardized tests like the SAT or ACT can better assess readiness and help improve STEM education outcomes.
Could reinstating testing affect UC’s diversity and access?
Yes, opponents worry that requiring standardized tests might create barriers for underrepresented and lower-income students. Supporters contend that tests can serve as a fair metric of academic preparedness, potentially improving overall student success.
When might the UC system decide on changing admissions policies?
The UC Academic Senate’s Board of Admissions is expected to discuss and propose policy changes in the upcoming academic year, with a decision likely by late 2024 or early 2025.
Source: Hacker News
