For a versatile starting point, I’d make the Womier Double-Shot PBT Keycap Set in Brown and Grey my best overall pick: its understated colors and Cherry profile suit a wide range of setups. The Thyrnovyn Macaron set stands out for a softer pastel palette, while the Womier Pudding set is the clearer choice when showing off keyboard lighting matters most. Across these mechanical keyboard keycap sets, the main tradeoffs are durable PBT versus translucent shine-through designs, familiar Cherry versus taller or sculpted profiles, and broad layout coverage versus a more distinctive look. Compatibility matters just as much as appearance, since a set can miss the keys needed for your keyboard’s layout. Read on for the full breakdown, selection criteria, and guidance for matching a set to your board.
Get business pricing on monitors, keyboards and dev gear
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
Key Takeaways
- Everyday versatility favors classic Cherry-profile sets: Womier’s brown-and-grey PBT set and Thyrnovyn’s Macaron set offer familiar shapes, while the first leans restrained and the second more playful.
- Lighting needs point to translucent designs: Womier’s 164-key Pudding set offers broad coverage for shine-through styling; opaque PBT sets prioritize a more solid appearance instead.
- Material and lighting are separate choices: Several sets use PBT, while other options rely on translucent PC and ABS or a mixed PC+ABS build. Buyers should check the listed material rather than assuming every glowing set is PBT.
- Profile changes the feel as well as the look: Cherry-profile options are familiar to many typists, while MDA and MOA sets offer a more visibly sculpted or playful alternative.
- More keys can simplify compatibility, but cannot guarantee it: The 164-key Womier Pudding set and 138-key Dagaladoo Matcha set offer broad coverage, while 115-key translucent sets call for closer layout checks.
| mechanical keyboard keycap set | Key count | Material | Profile | Color |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HITIME XVX Black Clear Keycap | 119 | Polycarbonate | Cherry | Black |
| Thyrnovyn 126-Key PBT Double-S | 126 | PBT | Cherry | — |
| Womier Double-Shot PBT Keycap | 138 | PBT | Cherry | Brown and grey |
| OHY Jelly Gradient 132-Key Shi | 132 | PBT and translucent PC | HOA | Flesh pink gradient |
| OHY XVX Starry Side-Printed Tr | 122 | Polycarbonate (PC) and ABS | MDA | — |
| Womier Black PBT Shine-Through | 164 | PBT | OEM | Black |
| dagaladoo Matcha Green Double- | 138 keys listed; product information also lists 131 buttons | PBT | Cherry | Matcha green |
| EPOMAKER Lusterfly Jelly Keyca | 123 | ABS and polycarbonate | MDA | Blue |
| Dagaladoo Green Frog MOA PBT K | 132 | PBT | MOA | — |
| 137-Key Anime PBT Keycap Set f | 137 | PBT | Cherry | — |
| Dagaladoo Clear Translucent MD | 115 | Polycarbonate (PC) | MDA | — |
| Womier Jelly Ceramic Style Key | 115 | Polycarbonate (PC) | MDA | White Clear |
| dagaladoo Translucent MDA Prof | 115 | Polycarbonate | MDA | Black and grey |
| TYRIXKI 126-Key PBT MOA Profil | 126 | PBT | MOA | Rainbow Candy |
More Details on Our Top Picks
HITIME XVX Black Clear Keycap Set, 119 Keys, Cherry Profile
Matte black tops and translucent sides make this set a good fit for buyers who want backlighting to glow around the keys rather than shine through the legends. Its Cherry profile keeps the shape familiar for those replacing standard-profile caps, while the polycarbonate construction gives the set a different look and feel from the PBT options here. Compared with the OHY Jelly Gradient 132-Key Set, the HITIME set has a darker, more restrained appearance and diffuses light from the sides instead of emphasizing a colorful translucent gradient. The tradeoff is its 119-key count, which may leave less flexibility for unusual layouts, and its compatibility is limited to cross-shaped switches. Choose it for a subtle lighting effect, not if you need shine-through legends or a broad layout-specific kit.
Pros:- Translucent sides diffuse backlighting into a soft glow
- Cherry profile offers a familiar shape for standard-profile users
- Polycarbonate is described as resistant to wear and yellowing
- Includes 119 keycaps and a keycap puller
Cons:- Does not provide the same through-the-legend lighting effect as shine-through sets
- 119 keys may not cover every nonstandard layout
- Requires cross-shaped switches, and the keyboard is sold separately
Best for: Owners of MX-style mechanical keyboards who want understated black caps with a soft side-lit effect.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need legends illuminated through the key tops or extra keys for less common layouts.
- Brand:HITIME
- Key count:119
- Material:Polycarbonate
- Profile:Cherry
- Color:Black
- Layout:QWERTY
- Compatibility:Mechanical keyboards with cross-shaped switches
- Package contents:119 keycaps and 1 keycap puller
- Warranty:2 years
Our verdict“Pick the HITIME set if you want a restrained black Cherry-profile look with side-diffused lighting rather than illuminated legends.”
Thyrnovyn 126-Key PBT Double-Shot Macaron Keycap Set, Cherry Profile
The pastel macaron palette gives this set a clear visual identity, while its double-shot PBT construction suits buyers who want color without giving up durable legends. A matte finish is described as resisting sweat, oil, and shine, which can help the keys retain a less glossy appearance through regular use. Against the retro brown-and-grey Womier Double-Shot PBT Set, Thyrnovyn is the brighter, more playful choice; Womier’s 138 keys may suit buyers who want broader key coverage better. Thyrnovyn’s 126-key ANSI-oriented kit covers common 60% through full-size layouts, but it is not a universal fit and requires Cherry MX-style switches. The keyboard is not included, so check the board’s layout and switch stems before buying.
Pros:- Double-shot PBT construction is designed to keep legends from fading
- Matte finish is described as resisting sweat, oil, and shine
- 126 keys support many standard ANSI layouts
- Includes a keycap puller
Cons:- Limited to Cherry MX-style switches
- Pastel colors may not suit restrained or monochrome setups
- Keyboard is not included
Best for: ANSI keyboard owners seeking pastel colors, a matte PBT surface, and double-shot legends in a familiar Cherry profile.
Not ideal for: Buyers with non-ANSI or unusual layouts, or those who want a neutral colorway or non-MX-style switch compatibility.
- Brand:Thyrnovyn
- Key count:126
- Material:PBT
- Construction:Double-shot
- Profile:Cherry
- Color theme:Pastel macaron
- Layout compatibility:Most standard ANSI 60%, 65%, 75%, and 100% layouts
- Switch compatibility:Cherry MX-style switches
- Included:126 keycaps and keycap puller
Our verdict“Choose Thyrnovyn for pastel styling and double-shot PBT in a standard ANSI kit, provided your board uses MX-style switches.”
Womier Double-Shot PBT Keycap Set, Cherry Profile, Brown and Grey
138 double-shot PBT keycaps give this Womier set the broadest stated layout coverage among these five picks, including common compact boards and full-size keyboards. The brown-and-grey colorway also favors a subdued, retro setup over the candy pastels of the Thyrnovyn set or the illuminated novelty styles from OHY. Its Cherry profile is a familiar choice for buyers replacing standard-profile caps, and the included puller makes installation easier. The main compromise is aesthetic: this palette is deliberately muted, so it will not deliver the color or lighting drama of the OHY Jelly Gradient. The listing describes PBT as designed to resist wear, scratches, and oiling, but buyers should still verify their keyboard’s layout and key sizes before ordering. It is a keycap set only, not a keyboard upgrade bundle.
Pros:- 138 keys support several common keyboard sizes and key counts
- Double-shot PBT is designed to resist wear, scratches, and oiling
- Cherry profile provides a familiar key shape
- Includes a keycap puller
Cons:- Brown-and-grey styling may feel too muted for colorful setups
- Keyboard is not included
- Layout coverage still requires checking key sizes against the specific board
Best for: Owners of common 60%, 65%, 75%, or full-size boards who want a subdued retro palette and extra layout coverage.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking bright colors, translucent lighting effects, or a set tailored to a nonstandard layout not listed.
- Brand:Womier
- Key count:138
- Material:PBT
- Manufacturing:Double-shot
- Profile:Cherry
- Color:Brown and grey
- Compatible layouts:60%, 65%, 75%, and full-size keyboards
- Compatible key counts:61, 64, 68, 84, 87, 100, 104, and 108 keys
- Included accessory:Keycap puller
Our verdict“Choose Womier when broad coverage for common layouts and a restrained retro look matter more than bright color or lighting effects.”
OHY Jelly Gradient 132-Key Shine-Through Keycap Set, Flesh Pink
If your priority is making keyboard lighting visible through the keys, this 132-key shine-through set is the most direct match in this group. Its double-shot design combines PBT and translucent PC in a flesh-pink jelly gradient, giving RGB lighting a more pronounced role than the side glow of the HITIME Black Clear set. The rounded HOA profile also separates it from the three Cherry-profile options, so it suits buyers who want a different key shape as well as a bolder appearance. Layout support spans 60% to 100% boards, with MX-style compatibility listed for Cherry, Gateron, and Kailh. The tradeoff is a distinctive pink translucent look that may dominate a restrained setup; the Womier brown-and-grey set is a safer fit for understated styling. The keyboard is not included.
Pros:- Translucent construction lets RGB backlighting shine through
- 132 keys support layouts from 60% through 100%
- HOA profile offers an alternative to the Cherry-profile sets
- Lists compatibility with Cherry MX, Gateron, and Kailh MX-style switches
Cons:- Flesh-pink gradient is a strong style choice that may not suit every setup
- Compatibility is limited to MX-style switches
- Keyboard is not included
Best for: RGB keyboard owners who want translucent pink gradient caps and a rounded profile across a common layout.
Not ideal for: Buyers who prefer neutral keycaps, top-lit legends, or a familiar Cherry profile.
- Key count:132
- Material:PBT and translucent PC
- Profile:HOA
- Color:Flesh pink gradient
- Keycap type:Double-shot, shine-through
- Layout compatibility:60%, 65%, 75%, 80%, 96%, and 100%
- Switch compatibility:Cherry MX, Gateron, and Kailh MX-style switches
- Included accessory:Keycap puller
- Keyboard included:No
Our verdict“Pick the OHY Jelly Gradient if visible RGB and a rounded HOA profile matter more than a subtle colorway or Cherry-profile familiarity.”
OHY XVX Starry Side-Printed Translucent Black Crystal MDA Profile Keycap Set (Sparkle Finish), 122-Keys, Double Shot PC+ABS for MX Switches & ANSI Layout Mechanical Keyboards
The starry black crystal finish gives this set a more decorative, light-catching look than the plain black HITIME caps, while its side-printed legends keep the tops visually uncluttered. Backlighting can accent the translucent sparkle, but the side-printed legends are a different choice from the OHY Jelly Gradient’s shine-through treatment: buyers who want letters lit from above should compare those designs carefully. Its MDA profile also stands apart from the Cherry-profile Womier and Thyrnovyn sets, offering a distinct key shape for buyers who want something other than the familiar low profile. The 122-key kit is specified for ANSI layouts and MX-compatible switches, including Cherry, Gateron, and Kailh clones. The material blend is PC and ABS rather than the PBT used in several alternatives, and the keyboard is sold separately.
Pros:- Sparkle finish adds visual texture under backlighting
- Double-shot side legends are designed to resist fading and wear
- MDA profile distinguishes it from the Cherry-profile options
- 122 keys and a puller are included
Cons:- Side-printed legends may be less familiar than top-printed legends
- PC and ABS construction differs from the PBT sets in this roundup
- Compatibility is specified for ANSI layouts and MX-style switches
Best for: ANSI keyboard owners who want translucent black caps with a sparkle finish, side legends, and an MDA profile.
Not ideal for: Buyers who prefer traditional top-printed legends, PBT construction, or compatibility beyond MX-style switches and ANSI layouts.
- Brand and model:OHY XVX Starry
- Key count:122
- Profile:MDA
- Material:Polycarbonate (PC) and ABS
- Compatibility:MX switches and MX clones, including Cherry, Gateron, and Kailh
- Layout:ANSI
- Legend style:Side-printed
- Printing method:Double-shot
- Included accessory:Keycap puller
Our verdict“Choose the OHY XVX Starry set for a distinctive side-printed, sparkling black look, but skip it if you need top legends or PBT.”
Womier Black PBT Shine-Through Pudding Keycaps, 164-Key Set
The Womier is the clearest choice here for buyers who want their keyboard’s RGB to be part of the look: its translucent pudding sides let light spill around the keys, while the legends themselves remain suited to a dark, understated color scheme. Compared with the 137-Key Anime PBT Set, which emphasizes shine-through legends and a Cherry profile, this set offers more keys for layout coverage and an OEM profile. Its double-shot PBT construction and textured finish are aimed at resisting wear, and the included puller and storage box make swapping and keeping spare caps simpler. The tradeoff is that OEM sits taller than Cherry, and the product data advises checking your exact layout despite broad MX-stem compatibility. Choose it for side-lit RGB, not if you want a low-profile feel or a specific layout guarantee.
Pros:- Translucent sides make RGB lighting visible around the keys.
- Double-shot PBT construction and thick walls are designed for lasting use.
- 164 keys offer broad coverage across standard and non-standard MX layouts.
- Includes a keycap puller and storage box.
Cons:- OEM profile is taller than Cherry-profile alternatives such as the dagaladoo Matcha Green set.
- A specific keyboard layout may still need checking before purchase.
Best for: RGB keyboard owners with MX-stem boards who want light to glow around dark keycaps and need a large set for varied layouts.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking shine-through legends, a lower Cherry profile, or confirmed compatibility with an unusual keyboard layout.
- Brand:Womier
- Key count:164
- Material:PBT
- Construction:Double-shot
- Profile:OEM
- Color:Black
- Compatibility:Most MX-stem mechanical keyboards; standard and non-standard layouts
- Included accessories:Keycap puller and storage box
Our verdict“Choose the Womier if side-lit RGB and broad key coverage matter more to you than a lower Cherry profile.”
dagaladoo Matcha Green Double-Shot PBT Keycaps, Cherry Profile, 138-Key Set
For a restrained color change rather than a novelty theme, this matcha green Cherry-profile set is the most conventional-feeling pick in this group. The shorter Cherry profile gives it a different hand feel from the taller OEM Womier pudding set, while double-shot PBT legends are designed to resist wearing away. Compatibility information lists US and UK layouts and a wide range of keyboard sizes, which makes it a practical replacement set for many MX-style boards. The main limitation is its non-transparent legends: unlike the anime set, it won’t let RGB shine through the characters. There is also conflicting product information, listing both 138 keys and 131 buttons, so I would verify the included count before relying on less common layout coverage. Its 18-month warranty is a useful stated term, but the count discrepancy keeps this from being the safest pick for specialized layouts.
Pros:- Cherry profile offers a familiar, lower-feeling alternative to the OEM Womier pudding set.
- Double-shot PBT legends are designed to resist wear.
- Compatibility information includes US and UK layouts and many keyboard sizes.
- Product information lists an 18-month warranty.
Cons:- Non-transparent legends do not illuminate like those on the 137-Key Anime PBT Set.
- Product information conflicts between 138 keys and 131 buttons.
- Cherry MX-style compatibility may not cover non-MX switch stems.
Best for: MX-style keyboard owners who prefer a familiar Cherry profile, a muted green palette, and durable legends over RGB effects.
Not ideal for: RGB-focused buyers or people who need a certain key count for a less common layout without first confirming the set contents.
- Key count:138 keys listed; product information also lists 131 buttons
- Material:PBT
- Construction:Double-shot
- Profile:Cherry
- Color:Matcha green
- Layout compatibility:US and UK; listed for 61/64/66/68/84/87/96/98/100/104/108-key keyboards
- Switch compatibility:Cherry MX-style
- Warranty:18 months
Our verdict“Pick this set for a familiar Cherry-profile feel and subdued matcha color, provided you confirm the key count for your layout.”
EPOMAKER Lusterfly Jelly Keycaps Set, 123 Keys, Blue
The Lusterfly is the style-first choice in this lineup: its blue jelly-like ABS and polycarbonate caps diffuse RGB into a soft glow rather than presenting the darker, more focused lighting of the Womier pudding set. An MDA profile also distinguishes it from the Cherry-profile dagaladoo Matcha and anime sets, so buyers should choose it for its look and shape rather than assume a familiar profile. Side-printed legends and a butterfly accent key add to the decorative effect, but the supplied description calls the caps non-shine-through. That means the translucent material can spread light without guaranteeing illuminated legends—a meaningful distinction for anyone who types by backlight. The 123-key count covers several common layouts, though the listed compatibility is limited to MX switches and compatible clones. It makes more sense as a visual refresh than as a universal lighting upgrade.
Pros:- Translucent construction diffuses RGB for a softer lighting effect than the Womier pudding set.
- MDA profile gives the set a distinct alternative to the Cherry-profile options.
- 123 keys support several listed keyboard sizes.
- Includes a butterfly accent keycap and keycap puller.
Cons:- The caps are described as non-shine-through, so legends may not light up.
- Compatibility is limited to MX switches and compatible clones.
- ABS and polycarbonate construction differs from the PBT used in the Womier and dagaladoo sets.
Best for: MX-style keyboard owners who want blue translucent caps, a decorative accent key, and a soft RGB-diffusing appearance.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need clearly illuminated legends, use non-MX switch stems, or prefer Cherry or OEM profiles.
- Key count:123
- Material:ABS and polycarbonate
- Profile:MDA
- Compatibility:MX switches and compatible clones
- Supported layouts:61/68/84/87/98/100/104-key
- Legend style:Side-printed
- Color:Blue
- Included accessories:Keycap puller and butterfly accent keycap
Our verdict“Choose the Lusterfly for a blue translucent, decorative look, not for reliably illuminated legends or broad switch-stem compatibility.”
Dagaladoo Green Frog MOA PBT Keycap Set
Among these five, the Green Frog set puts the most emphasis on an illustrated theme: frogs, raindrops, flowers, and a yellow-to-green gradient give it a distinctive rainy-pond look rather than the lighting-led style of the Womier pudding caps. Its dye-sublimated legends are designed to resist fading, and PBT provides a familiar durable material choice. The MOA profile sets it apart from the Cherry-profile matcha set and anime set, so this is a more specific choice for people who like that taller, rounded shape. A 132-key count and stated support for 60%, 65%, 75%, 96%, and full-size boards cover several common formats. The tradeoff is that a playful, high-contrast theme won’t suit a minimalist desk, and profile preference is personal. The set includes a puller, but no keyboard or switches.
Pros:- Distinct frog, raindrop, and flower design stands apart from the lineup’s plain and lighting-focused sets.
- Dye-sublimated legends are designed to resist fading.
- 132 keys are listed for several common keyboard sizes.
- Compatible with MX-style switches, including Cherry and Gateron.
Cons:- The decorative theme may not suit understated or uniform keyboard builds.
- MOA profile differs from the familiar Cherry profile offered by the matcha and anime sets.
- The set does not include a keyboard or switches.
Best for: MX-style keyboard owners who want a colorful frog-and-pond theme, dye-sublimated legends, and coverage for common compact through full-size layouts.
Not ideal for: Minimalist buyers, RGB users looking for shine-through legends, or anyone unsure they will like the MOA profile.
- Key count:132
- Material:PBT
- Profile:MOA
- Compatibility:60%, 65%, 75%, 96%, and 100% keyboards
- Switch compatibility:MX-style, including Cherry and Gateron
- Printing:Dye sublimation
- Layout:QWERTY
- Included accessory:Keycap puller
Our verdict“Choose this set if the frog-themed artwork and MOA shape are the point of your build, rather than RGB shine-through or a neutral look.”
137-Key Anime PBT Keycap Set for Mechanical Keyboards
This anime-themed set is the best match here for buyers who want RGB to pass through the legends themselves, not just glow around translucent keycap sides as with the Womier pudding set. Its double-shot PBT construction pairs that lighting feature with a Cherry profile, making it a more familiar-feeling option than the MDA-profile EPOMAKER Lusterfly. The 137-key count is listed for 60%, 65%, 75%, and 100% layouts, giving it useful coverage across common board sizes. The tradeoff is a vivid anime-inspired design that will dominate a build rather than blend into it. Compatibility is stated for MX-style switches, so buyers with other stems should check their board before ordering. It is a focused choice: stronger for backlit character legends and themed builds than for shoppers seeking a restrained colorway or translucent side glow.
Pros:- Shine-through legends allow RGB to show through the characters, unlike the non-shine-through Lusterfly description.
- Double-shot PBT construction is designed to resist wear and fading.
- Cherry profile offers a familiar alternative to the MOA Green Frog set and MDA Lusterfly.
- 137 keys are listed for 60%, 65%, 75%, and 100% layouts.
Cons:- The vibrant anime design may overwhelm a restrained keyboard build.
- Compatibility is listed for MX-style switches, not all mechanical switch stems.
- The set includes keycaps only, not a keyboard.
Best for: Owners of MX-style keyboards who want a vivid anime theme, Cherry profile, and RGB-lit legends across several common layouts.
Not ideal for: Buyers who prefer subdued keycaps, need listed support for unusual layouts, or want light to glow mainly through translucent sides.
- Key count:137
- Material:PBT
- Construction:Double-shot
- Profile:Cherry
- Switch compatibility:MX-style switches
- Supported layouts:100%, 75%, 65%, and 60%
- Legend type:Shine-through
- Warranty:18 months
Our verdict“Choose this set if you want an expressive anime design with RGB-lit legends and your board uses MX-style switches.”
Dagaladoo Clear Translucent MDA Profile Keycap Set, 115 Keys
The Dagaladoo Clear Translucent MDA set suits buyers who want lighting to define their keyboard’s look instead of opaque colors or printed artwork. Its clear PC construction lets backlighting shine through, while the rounded MDA profile provides a broad, relatively flat surface across the keys. Compared with the black-and-grey Dagaladoo set, this version keeps the appearance simpler and puts more emphasis on visible RGB. The 115-key count is aimed at full-size, 75%, and smaller layouts, though buyers with unusual layouts should check their key requirements before ordering. The main tradeoff is switch fit: compatibility is specified for MX-style switches, not other stem types. Its clear surface may also be less appealing to anyone who wants strong color contrast or discreet legends.
Pros:- Translucent PC lets keyboard backlighting shine through
- Rounded MDA profile offers a broad, flat typing surface
- 115 keys are specified for full-size, 75%, and smaller keyboards
Cons:- Compatibility is limited to MX-style switches
- Clear styling offers less color contrast than the black-and-grey Dagaladoo set
- Layout coverage may not include every nonstandard keyboard arrangement
Best for: RGB-focused typists who want clear, understated keycaps for an MX-style full-size, 75%, or smaller keyboard.
Not ideal for: Owners of keyboards with non-MX stems or buyers who prefer opaque caps, subdued lighting, or a dark color scheme.
- Material:Polycarbonate (PC)
- Profile:MDA
- Key count:115
- Switch compatibility:MX-style switches
- Keyboard size compatibility:Full-size, 75%, and smaller keyboards
- Backlighting:Translucent caps allow keyboard lighting to shine through
Our verdict“Choose this set for a clean, clear RGB look on an MX-style keyboard, but skip it if you need opaque caps or non-MX compatibility.”
Womier Jelly Ceramic Style Keycaps, White Clear Shine-Through, MDA Profile, 115-Key Set
The Womier Jelly Ceramic Style set is the more distinctive choice for buyers who want translucent caps with a textured, ceramic-inspired look rather than the plain clarity of the Dagaladoo Clear set. Its white-clear PC caps let RGB show through, and the MDA profile gives the keys a broad, rounded shape. Womier lists compatibility with MX-style boards from brands including GMMK, Wooting, Razer, Corsair, and Steelseries, making its stated fit range more specific than Dagaladoo’s general MX-style description. That does not guarantee a fit for every layout or nonstandard stem, so checking the keyboard’s key sizes still matters. The tradeoff is upkeep: translucent surfaces can make dirt or wear more visible. A one-year warranty is included, but the clear finish may not suit buyers after a low-maintenance, opaque set.
Pros:- Translucent PC caps allow RGB lighting to show through
- Ceramic-style texture gives the jelly look a distinct surface character
- MDA profile provides broad, rounded key surfaces
- Lists compatibility with several MX-style keyboard brands and includes a one-year warranty
Cons:- Clear material may show dirt or wear more visibly over time
- Nonstandard switch stem compatibility is not guaranteed
- The 115-key count may not cover every unusual layout
Best for: RGB enthusiasts who want a white-clear, jelly-inspired look and use a keyboard with MX-style stems.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want opaque, low-visibility wear, or owners of keyboards with nonstandard switch stems or unusual key layouts.
- Brand:Womier
- Model number:JM-AZ-129
- Material:Polycarbonate (PC)
- Profile:MDA
- Key count:115
- Color:White Clear
- Compatibility:MX-style switches; listed examples include GMMK, Wooting, Razer, Corsair, and Steelseries
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“Pick Womier for a textured, white-clear RGB style and broader stated brand compatibility, provided visible wear and layout fit are acceptable.”
dagaladoo Translucent MDA Profile Keycaps Set, 115 Keys, Black and Grey
For a darker RGB setup, the dagaladoo Black and Grey MDA set offers a more defined color scheme than the all-clear Dagaladoo set while retaining translucent, shine-through construction. Its black-and-grey palette gives the board more visual contrast, and the 115-key count is listed for 60%, 65%, 70%, and full-size keyboards. That stated range makes it a practical fit for several common sizes, though buyers with layouts outside those categories should verify their key sizes. Like the Womier Jelly set, it uses a translucent finish, but this option favors a restrained dark look over Womier’s white-clear, textured style. A keycap puller is included; the product is still keycaps only, not a keyboard. Compatibility is stated for Cherry MX-style switches, and the supplied waterproof claim lacks detail, so I would not treat it as a substitute for careful spill handling.
Pros:- Black-and-grey palette gives a darker look than the clear Dagaladoo set
- Translucent polycarbonate lets lighting shine through
- 115 keys are listed for several common keyboard sizes
- Keycap puller is included
Cons:- Compatibility is specified for Cherry MX-style switches
- The waterproof claim is not supported with a rating or further detail
- The set does not include a keyboard
Best for: Owners of 60%, 65%, 70%, or full-size MX-style keyboards who want dark colors with backlighting visible through the caps.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking opaque legends, documented spill protection, or a guaranteed fit for layouts beyond the stated size range.
- Material:Polycarbonate
- Profile:MDA
- Key count:115
- Color:Black and grey
- Layout:QWERTY
- Switch compatibility:Cherry MX-style switches
- Keyboard size compatibility:60%, 65%, 70%, and full-size keyboards
- Included accessory:Keycap puller
Our verdict“Choose this set for dark, shine-through caps across several common MX-style layouts, but do not rely on its unspecified waterproof claim.”
TYRIXKI 126-Key PBT MOA Profile Rainbow Candy Keycap Set
The TYRIXKI Rainbow Candy set is the outlier here: it trades the translucent RGB focus of the Dagaladoo and Womier sets for a colorful, opaque PBT design. Its 126-key count covers a broad list of layouts, including compact boards and full-size arrangements, while the rounded MOA profile gives the caps a different shape from the MDA options. PBT with a matte, anti-grease finish favors buyers who want a less glossy surface, and dye-sublimated legends are specified for the key markings. The compromise is compatibility: the set is described for most Cherry MX-style switch keyboards, not every stem type. It also includes only keycaps and a puller, so it cannot add shine-through RGB. Compared with the translucent options, this is the pick for color and coverage, not lighting effects.
Pros:- PBT construction has a matte, anti-grease finish
- 126 keys support a wide range of listed keyboard layouts
- Dye-sublimated legends are specified
- MOA profile offers a rounded alternative to the MDA sets
- Keycap puller is included
Cons:- Not a shine-through set like the Dagaladoo and Womier options
- Compatibility is limited to supported Cherry MX-style switch keyboards
- The keyboard is not included
Best for: Owners of supported Cherry MX-style keyboards who want a colorful matte set and broad stated layout coverage without prioritizing RGB shine-through.
Not ideal for: RGB-focused buyers, users with non-MX stems, or anyone who prefers a restrained color palette or MDA profile.
- Brand:TYRIXKI
- Material:PBT
- Key count:126
- Profile:MOA
- Color:Rainbow Candy
- Printing process:Dye sublimation
- Compatibility:Most Cherry MX-style switch mechanical keyboards
- Compatible layouts:61, 64, 68, 75, 84, 87, 96, 98, 104, and 108 keys
- Included accessory:Keycap puller
Our verdict“Choose TYRIXKI for colorful matte PBT caps and extensive listed layout coverage, but pick a translucent set if visible RGB is your priority.”
How We Picked
I compared these sets on the factors that shape a keycap purchase: material and construction, profile, listed key count and layout coverage, lighting behavior, and the practical fit of each design for different setups. A large count can help with less common layouts, but I treated compatibility as something to verify rather than assuming that every extra key fits every keyboard. I also separated shine-through designs from opaque sets because they serve different goals, not because one is automatically better.
The order gives priority to everyday versatility: familiar profiles, useful coverage, and designs that can work beyond one highly specific aesthetic. More specialized picks rank lower not as poor choices, but because their translucent finishes, distinctive profiles, or theme-led colors suit narrower preferences. Product details provided for this roundup do not establish testing results, so I avoid claims about typing feel, shine-through brightness, or long-term wear that cannot be confirmed from the specifications.
| mechanical keyboard keycap set | Material | Profile | Switch compatibility |
|---|---|---|---|
| HITIME XVX Black Clear Keycap | Polycarbonate | Cherry | — |
| Thyrnovyn 126-Key PBT Double-S | PBT | Cherry | Cherry MX-style switches |
| Womier Double-Shot PBT Keycap | PBT | Cherry | — |
| OHY Jelly Gradient 132-Key Shi | PBT and translucent PC | HOA | Cherry MX, Gateron, and Kailh MX-style switches |
| OHY XVX Starry Side-Printed Tr | Polycarbonate (PC) and ABS | MDA | — |
| Womier Black PBT Shine-Through | PBT | OEM | — |
| dagaladoo Matcha Green Double- | PBT | Cherry | Cherry MX-style |
| EPOMAKER Lusterfly Jelly Keyca | ABS and polycarbonate | MDA | — |
| Dagaladoo Green Frog MOA PBT K | PBT | MOA | MX-style, including Cherry and Gateron |
| 137-Key Anime PBT Keycap Set f | PBT | Cherry | MX-style switches |
| Dagaladoo Clear Translucent MD | Polycarbonate (PC) | MDA | MX-style switches |
| Womier Jelly Ceramic Style Key | Polycarbonate (PC) | MDA | — |
| dagaladoo Translucent MDA Prof | Polycarbonate | MDA | Cherry MX-style switches |
| TYRIXKI 126-Key PBT MOA Profil | PBT | MOA | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Mechanical Keyboard Keycap Sets
Before picking a colorway, I’d check the details that determine whether a set will work on your keyboard and still suit your routine after the novelty fades. These broader checks help separate a visually appealing set from a useful match.
Match the Key Layout, Not Just the Key Count
A set’s total number of keys is a starting point, not proof of compatibility. Compare the included modifier sizes and alternate keys with your keyboard, especially if it has a compact layout, split spacebars, or an unusual bottom row. A standard full-size board may need a number pad and navigation keys that a smaller set does not include. Sets with 138 or 164 keys can offer more options, but the count alone does not tell you which layout variants are in the box. Check the product’s key map before buying, and avoid assuming that ANSI and ISO layouts use identical keys.
Choose Material for the Surface You Want
PBT and ABS describe different plastics, but the label alone cannot predict every part of a keycap’s feel or durability. This roundup includes PBT sets alongside a translucent PC+ABS design, so material deserves a direct check rather than a guess based on appearance. Double-shot construction joins two molded layers and can keep legends from being a simple surface print, but it does not tell you how a keycap will feel in your hands. Shine-through construction can support a lit setup, while opaque caps make lighting less central to the design. If surface texture, legend construction, or wear resistance is a priority, look for those details in the listing instead of relying on color photography.
Treat Profile as a Fit and Preference Decision
Cherry, MDA, and MOA are not interchangeable names for the same shape. Profile affects row height and sculpting, which can change how a board looks and how familiar the key arrangement feels. If you are replacing caps on a keyboard you already enjoy, matching its existing profile is a low-risk way to keep the overall setup familiar. Trying a different profile can make a build feel more distinctive, but it may take time to adjust, and product names alone do not establish how it will suit your typing style. Check the seller’s profile description and compare it with your current set before making a style-led choice.
Decide Whether Your Lighting Should Show Through
Shine-through caps are most useful when the keyboard’s lighting should remain visible through or around the legends. Pudding designs typically make translucency a prominent part of the look, while clear and jelly-style sets can create a more glassy appearance. The visual result depends on the keyboard’s LEDs, their position, and the cap construction, so a product name cannot promise uniform brightness. If you rarely use backlighting, an opaque set may make more sense and give you a broader choice of solid colors and finishes. Check listing images and construction details for the actual legend and side-wall treatment rather than treating every translucent set as equivalent.
Balance Theme Appeal Against Everyday Versatility
A distinctive theme can make a keyboard feel personal, but it may be harder to pair with changing desk colors or devices. Restrained brown-and-grey or black-and-grey designs are easier to mix into different setups, while frog, anime, candy, and bold gradient themes make the keyboard a stronger visual feature. Neither approach is inherently more useful; the tradeoff is how much attention you want the caps to draw. If you are buying one set for a long-term daily board, think about whether you will still like the palette alongside future desk changes. For a themed build, verify that the accent keys and legends match the look you want, not only the main key colors.
Pay More Attention to Missing Information Than Extra Claims
Keycap listings do not always spell out every detail needed for a confident fit. Before ordering, look for a complete key map, supported layout, profile, material, legend method, and any stated compatibility limits. If a listing says “MX” compatibility, still check the stem type and your keyboard’s switch design rather than assuming all mechanical switches share the same mount. Larger kits can reduce the chance of missing a needed key, but they do not replace a clear compatibility chart. When a detail that matters to you is absent, seek clarification or choose a set with more complete specifications.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can I tell whether a keycap set will fit my keyboard layout?
Start with the keyboard’s layout and compare it against the set’s included key map, rather than relying on the total key count. Check the bottom row, right Shift, Enter key, and any nonstandard modifiers, since those are common sources of mismatch. A larger set may include useful alternatives, but only a diagram can confirm that the needed sizes are present. Also check whether the set is listed for ANSI, ISO, or both. If your board has an unusual layout, confirm compatibility before ordering.
Should I choose PBT or a translucent keycap set?
These describe different priorities rather than a simple either-or choice: PBT identifies a plastic, while translucent describes how light can pass through a cap. This roundup includes PBT sets aimed at solid-color styling and separate shine-through or translucent options for lighting-focused builds. Some products can combine material and lighting traits, so check the actual construction details rather than assuming one excludes the other. If backlighting is central to your setup, look closely at the legends and sides shown in listing images. If it is not, an opaque set may give you more freedom to choose a color and finish.
Will a different profile change how my keyboard feels?
It can change the shape and height of the key rows, which may affect how familiar the board feels when you type. Cherry is a familiar choice for many buyers, while MDA and MOA offer different shapes and a more distinctive visual profile. A profile name does not guarantee that you will prefer its feel, and preferences vary. If you are happy with your current keyboard, matching its profile can reduce the adjustment. If you want a different look, check the profile details and be open to a short adaptation period.
Are shine-through keycaps worth choosing if my keyboard has backlighting?
They make the most sense if you want lighting to remain visible through the legends or translucent portions of the caps. The effect varies with the keyboard’s LED placement and the cap’s construction, so “shine-through” does not guarantee a particular brightness or uniform appearance. Pudding and jelly-style sets can make translucency part of the overall design, while solid PBT sets may keep the focus on color and texture instead. If you usually keep lighting off, shine-through may be a lower priority than layout coverage or material. Compare product images and descriptions for the exact areas that transmit light.
Is a larger keycap set automatically a safer choice for a compact keyboard?
No. A larger key count can provide more alternate keys, but it does not confirm that the exact sizes your keyboard needs are included. Compact boards often use nonstandard bottom rows, smaller modifiers, or alternate spacebar arrangements. Compare the key map against your board’s layout and check the legend on each required key, since a set can have many keys without covering your particular configuration. A smaller kit with the correct variants can fit better than a larger kit with the wrong ones. Use the included-key diagram as the deciding evidence.
Conclusion
For the best overall balance, I’d start with the Womier Double-Shot PBT set in Brown and Grey, while the Thyrnovyn Macaron set is my best value-style choice for buyers who want pastel color and a familiar Cherry profile. Beginners can keep the decision straightforward with a restrained Cherry-profile set after checking the layout map; of these picks, the Womier brown-and-grey option is the easiest starting point for a broadly compatible look. For a more premium-feeling visual statement, I’d look to the OHY XVX Starry translucent MDA set, whose mixed PC+ABS construction and sparkle finish make it the most distinctive specialist choice here, though buyers should verify its profile and layout fit. If lighting is the priority, choose the Womier Pudding set; for a themed build, consider the frog, anime, matcha, or rainbow candy options. The right choice comes down to matching your layout first, then choosing the material, profile, and look you want to live with.
Columbus Day / Indigenous Peoples' Day Picks
long weekend sales
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
